Reprimands of Mawr Community Council by the Wales Audit Office

Many thanks, I agree that the relevant reports are for 2011 and 2015 and during these years the accounts were out of order in over fifty different ways. They may have been out of order prior to 2011, for an unknown number of years, and may still be out of order. The County Councillor, Ioan Richard, was subsequently forced to resign from the Community Council along with a few others. He has also resigned from the Planning Committee of Swansea County Council, and is a Rump Councillor, having been kicked in the rump by the electorate. The present Community Council is akin to a “Rump Council” (one which has overstayed its legitimacy). None were elected, they all signed on unopposed. So Mawr should be governed directly by the Assembly and Parliament until some semblance of financial order is recovered. In 1653 my ancestral cousin Oliver Cromwell dissolved the Rump Parliament. “In the name of God go!” and so on. A rump council is one which has overstayed its welcome, similarly for a rump (or remnant) County Councillor. Mawr Development Trust was liquidated with unknown debts in a creditor liquidation, owing unknown sums of money. During Cllr. Richard’s tenure, Mawr has been heavily damaged by extreme overdevelopment and wild price inflation, so it has become almost impossible for young people from Mawr to buy a house. So, “You have sat here (on your rump) too long for all the good you have done, begone I say, (as Armiger and Member of the Gentry of Wales), in the name of God go!” If accounts are out of order in so many ways for so many years, surely a police fraud investigation is in order? We still do not know to whom, exactly, the public money was given. The Audit only gives general figures.

cc M. P. for Gower
Chief Constable

In a message dated 02/03/2017 12:50:39 GMT Standard Time, Karan.Sanghera@audit.wales writes:

Dear Dr Evans,

Thank you for email of, 24 February 2017, in which you requested:

a copy of the two Audit Documents which severely reprimanded the [Mawr] Community Council in 2001 and again 2015”.

I have been unable to locate a report relating to the Mawr Community Council issued by us (or any other auditing body) in 2001. The appointed auditor issued two reports on the Mawr Community Council: one in 2011 and the other in 2015. These are available on our website, and can be accessed via the following links:

2011 report: http://www.audit.wales/publication/report-public-interest-mawr-community-council-audits-accounts-2005-06-2009-10

2015 report: http://www.audit.wales/publication/report-public-interest-mawr-community-council

I have passed your comments concerning the development trust and the running of the Council on to relevant colleagues to take into consideration in future audit work.

I have not applied any exemptions, however if you have any queries about my handling of your request please email or write to me.

Yours sincerely,

Karan Sanghera

Cynorthwyydd y Gyfraith a Moeseg / Law and Ethics Assistant

Ffôn / Tel: 029 2032 0552

E-bost: karan.sanghera

E-mail: karan.sanghera

Swyddfa Archwilio Cymru: www.archwilio.cymru

Wales Audit Office: www.audit.wales

Dilynwch / Follow @WalesAudit
Hoffwch ein tudalen / Like us on Facebook
Darllenwch ein blog / Read our blog

From: EMyrone@aol.com [mailto:EMyrone@aol.com]
Sent: 24 February 2017 09:14
To: bo.lehnert@alfvenlab.kth.se; avanderm@du.edu; dblake@no10.x.gsi.gov.uk; pennbonvivant@yahoo.com; raydela@sbcglobal.net; corbis@bigpond.net.au; normanpage@comcast.net; fritzius@bellsouth.net; garethjohnevans@hotmail.co.uk; rpmc_6@hotmail.com; burleigh.personal@gmail.com; alexhillgtz@yahoo.com; ccefalas@eie.gr; simon.cliffy@googlemail.com; fdamador@comcast.net; steve.bannister@econ.utah.edu; alwyn.vandermerwe@du.edu; henryk.ratajczak@gmail.com; croca@fc.ul.pt; dwlindstrom@gmail.com; cr1460solarinc@gmail.com; sean@somewhere.ws; norpag@att.net; kp.phys@btinternet.com; mail@horst-eckardt.de; rob@rfmicrosystems.co.uk; thenarmis@yahoo.com; Alwyn.VanDerMerwe@du.edu; dendavis@aol.com; k.pendergast@btinternet.com; mcp358@gmail.com; russdavis1234@yahoo.com; dewi.lewis1@btinternet.com; wsd@axenus.plus.com; arthur.turnerthomas@live.com; sianifan@sky.com; meirion66@yahoo.com; save.the.eagles2@gmail.com; vivswaby@gmail.com; socme.org@googlemail.com; cynthiamullan@tiscali.co.uk; ddangd@sc.rr.com; valamhic@gmail.com; lindaframe@btinternet.com; RobertGlynJones@btinternet.com; byron.davies.mp@parliament.uk; brigitterowlands@googlemail.com; helenjones9@hotmail.co.uk; blaenmyddfai@googlemail.com; gillianejones@yahoo.co.uk; mwjew@btinternet.com; geraint.thomas@swwmedia.co.uk; jason.phelps@bbc.co.uk; craighughes21@hotmail.com; Karan Sanghera <Karan.Sanghera@audit.wales>; derrickpotter@btinternet.com
Subject: Accounts of Mawr Community Council and Development Trust ac…

To Auditor’s Office, Welsh Assembly:

These accounts do not contain any information which show how taxpayers’ money was actually used. I assume that the accounts of Mawr Development Trust can be inspected at Companies House before it went bankrupt, owing creditors a lot of money. We still do not know how much money. Can you send me a copy of the two Audit Documents which severely reprimanded the Community Council in 2001 and again 2015. Your office described the Community Council as having completely failed the electorate, or similar wording. This was widely reported in the media. Subsequently, Cllr. Ioan Richard and others were forced to resign from the Community Council after a meeting in which the electorate voiced its displeasure at extreme overdevelopment. Cllr. Richard has also resigned from the Planning Committee of Swansea County Council and has little or no support in Mawr. I have filed several complaints against Cllr Richard with the Ombudsman’s Office concerning his abusive conduct. I feel that the Community Council should be wound up and Mawr run directly by the Assembly. In view of these auditing irregularities Cllr Richard should resign, they occurred during his tenure as County Councillor. I feel that there should be a fraud investigation.

Myron Evans, Armiger (2008) and Member of the Gentry (Burke’s Peerage and Gentry 2012), Civil List Pensioner (2005).

cc M. P. for Gower,

From: Karan.Sanghera
To: EMyrone
Sent: 23/02/2017 15:07:22 GMT Standard Time
Subj: Request for Information: Mawr Community Council and Development Trust accounts (IR590)

Dear Dr Evans,

Further to my email of 7 February 2017, I am responding to your request for information of 3 February 2017, which was for:

i) A complete record of accounts for the Mawr Community Council; and

ii) A complete record of accounts for the Mawr Development Trust.

Item (i)

With regard to item (i) of your request, please find attached the accounts we hold for the Mawr Community Council. I have redacted a small amount of information from the documents provided as I consider the exemption under section 40(2) (personal information) of the Freedom of Information Act 2000 applies. This section provides an absolute exemption and applies because disclosure would breach the data protection principles of the Data Protection Act 1998.

Item (ii)

We do not hold the accounts of the Mawr Development Trust as this is not an entity which we audit.

If you wish to complain about my handling of your request, please email or write to me.

I must also refer you to section 50 of the Freedom of Information Act under which you may apply to the Information Commissioner for a decision on whether or not your request has been dealt with in accordance with the Act. The Information Commissioner’s contact details are:

Information Commissioner’s Office
Wycliffe House
Water Lane
Wilmslow
Cheshire SK9 5AF

email : casework

Tel: 0303 123 1113
Fax: 01625 524510

You should note, however, that the Information Commissioner would normally expect you to have exhausted our internal complaints procedures before dealing with such an application. Further guidance may be found on the Information Commissioner’s website https://ico.org.uk/

If you have any queries, please do not hesitate to contact me.

Yours sincerely,

Karan Sanghera

Cynorthwyydd y Gyfraith a Moeseg / Law and Ethics Assistant

Ffôn / Tel: 029 2032 0552

E-bost: karan.sanghera

E-mail: karan.sanghera

Swyddfa Archwilio Cymru: www.archwilio.cymru

Wales Audit Office: www.audit.wales

Dilynwch / Follow @WalesAudit
Hoffwch ein tudalen / Like us on Facebook
Darllenwch ein blog / Read our blog

This email and any attached files is private. If you are not the intended recipient please destroy all copies and inform the sender by return email.

For further information on the Wales Audit Office and details of other ways to contact us please visit our website at www.audit.wales.

The Wales Audit Office welcomes correspondence in Welsh or English and we will respond to you in in the language you have used. Please let us know if you would like to receive future correspondence from us in Welsh. Corresponding in Welsh will not lead to a delay.

If you are attending a meeting at the Wales Audit Office, please let the organiser know if you would like to contribute to the meeting in Welsh and/or if you’d like to receive a Welsh language reception service during your visit.

Mae’r e-bost hwn ac unrhyw ffeiliau atodedig yn breifat. Os nad atoch chi y bwriadwyd anfon yr e-bost hwn dylech ddinistrio pob copi a hysbysu’r anfonwr drwy anfon e-bost yn ôl atynt.

Am fwy o wybodaeth am Swyddfa Archwilio Cymru a manylion am ffyrdd eraill o gysylltu â ni, ewch i’n gwefan www.archwilio.cymru.

Mae Swyddfa Archwilio Cymru yn croesawu gohebiaeth yn Gymraeg neu’n Saesneg a byddwn yn ymateb yn yr iaith rydych chi wedi ei defnyddio. Rhowch wybod os yr hoffech dderbyn gohebiaeth gennym yn Gymraeg yn y dyfodol. Ni fydd gohebu’n Gymraeg yn arwain at oedi.

Os byddwch yn mynychu cyfarfod yn Swyddfa Archwilio Cymru, rhowch wybod i’r trefnydd os yr hoffech gyfrannu i’r cyfarfod yn Gymraeg ac/neu os yr hoffech dderbyn gwasanaeth Cymraeg ar y dderbynfa yn ystod eich ymweliad.

This email and any attached files is private. If you are not the intended recipient please destroy all copies and inform the sender by return email.

For further information on the Wales Audit Office and details of other ways to contact us please visit our website at http://www.audit.wales.

The Wales Audit Office welcomes correspondence in Welsh or English and we will respond to you in in the language you have used. Please let us know if you would like to receive future correspondence from us in Welsh. Corresponding in Welsh will not lead to a delay.

If you are attending a meeting at the Wales Audit Office, please let the organiser know if you would like to contribute to the meeting in Welsh and/or if you’d like to receive a Welsh language reception service during your visit.

Mae’r e-bost hwn ac unrhyw ffeiliau atodedig yn breifat. Os nad atoch chi y bwriadwyd anfon yr e-bost hwn dylech ddinistrio pob copi a hysbysu’r anfonwr drwy anfon e-bost yn ôl atynt.

Am fwy o wybodaeth am Swyddfa Archwilio Cymru a manylion am ffyrdd eraill o gysylltu â ni, ewch i’n gwefan http://www.archwilio.cymru.

Mae Swyddfa Archwilio Cymru yn croesawu gohebiaeth yn Gymraeg neu’n Saesneg a byddwn yn ymateb yn yr iaith rydych chi wedi ei defnyddio. Rhowch wybod os yr hoffech dderbyn gohebiaeth gennym yn Gymraeg yn y dyfodol. Ni fydd gohebu’n Gymraeg yn arwain at oedi.

Os byddwch yn mynychu cyfarfod yn Swyddfa Archwilio Cymru, rhowch wybod i’r trefnydd os yr hoffech gyfrannu i’r cyfarfod yn Gymraeg ac/neu os yr hoffech dderbyn gwasanaeth Cymraeg ar y dderbynfa yn ystod eich ymweliad.


%d bloggers like this: