Notes for UFT313

April 27, 2015

Many thanks for going through this stuff. Sean Carroll lectured to Harvard graduates, then at UCSB, Chicago and Caltech. I will concentrate around Note 313(6) to extend the second Bianchi identity to include torsion. The expressions for the covariant derivative of any tensor and for the commutator of covariant derivatives acting on any tensor are given by Carroll in his chapter three, and in many UFT papers, giving much more detail than Carroll. The first Evans identity (the cyclical torsion identity) was discovered a few months after UFT88 in UFT109 and is an exact identity like the Jacobi identity and Cartan identity. The main theme of the paper is to show that the second Bianchi identity becomes completely different when torsion is included. It develops UFT88, UFT109, UFT255 and UFT281. As you know the Einstein field equation rests directly on the original 1902 second Bianchi identity without torsion, so the Einstein field equation is totally wrong. No longer does this statement generate waves of shock horror.

In a message dated 27/04/2015 10:35:58 GMT Daylight Time, writes:

Understanding these notes requires really some concentration. With your comments it becomes clearer now. Could you please resend notes 5 and 6, I do not have them at hand here today.

Horst

EMyrone@aol.com hat am 26. April 2015 um 08:52 geschrieben:

Eq. (15) of Note 313(2) is constructed from Eq. (14) of that note, which is an exact identity. So Eq. (15) is also an exact identity. Eq. (16) of that note is Eq. (105) of UFT255. It is assumed that Eq. (16) is a solution of Eq. (15). Adding Eqs. (15) and (16) gives Eq. (1) of Note 303(4), which shows that Eq. (16) is true, and so is a solution of Eq. (15). The identities (5) and (6) of Note 313(4) are obtained from the identity (3) by cyclic permutation of the indices lambda, nu and rho. In the same way, these indices can be cyclically permuted in the Cartan identity (2).

Sent: 25/04/2015 16:17:03 GMT Daylight Time
Subj: note 313(4)

Eq.(1) is constructed in a way that the terms in each line come from
known identities, thus making their sum valid.
I do not understand why the new identities (4-6) should be valid in
general. These seem to be constructed from columns of eq.(1). In this
way their validity is sufficient to validate (1), but the conditions
(4-6) are not necessary to fulfill (1), it is not an equivalence relation.
Eq.(3) is the second Bianchi identity and valid independently.

Horst

a313thpapernotes5.pdf

a313thpapernotes6.pdf

a313thpapernotes7.pdf

Observations on the British General Election

April 27, 2015

My main comment is that the politicians are almost completely irrelevant to a Welsh speaking community such as Mawr. They are inevitably self seekers, very few can speak the Welsh language. The second comment is based on a survey that I carried out recently which showed that the great majority of Swansea County Councillors are elected for many years on a small minority of the electoral register. The great majority of Community Councillors are never elected at all. Obviously this is not democracy. I knew this when I was about five years old so have never voted in a general election. The only meaningful election is a referendum with compulsory voting and proportional representation. This year the candidates have given up even trying to put mail on my doormat. It is not possible for any intelligent person to participate in such a system. However one can suggest reforms. Individually the candidates may be earnest, but they are trapped in a meaningless system. There were some interesting discussions with the Labour candidate for Gower. On the question of conservation of heritage it was agreed that the interior and exterior of houses, chapels and churches in a traditional community should be rigorously conserved. The Labour Party has drifted far away from its Bevanite principles and is only infinitesimally different from the tories. Bevanite socialist principles would prohibit the use of land and houses for parasitic, foreign based, capitalist profiteering. What usually happens is that houses are bought and their value artificially inflated way out of the reach of local people. So an area such as Mawr becomes a commuter area with a few people living in large, luxurious houses and the rest crammed in to an ancient council estate. Mawr should be a Bro Iaith, a semi autonomous region into which all immigration is strictly prohibited without a Welsh language test. In particular areas such as this should be protected from illegal bigotry against the Welsh language. Development should be entirely stopped in Mawr. If a house has been inflated so that it costs a million pounds for example, it should be taken over by the semi autonomous government and put into Trust for Welsh speakers. A fair price would be paid for it, much less than a million pounds. The establishment of such houses is overt colonialism, which should be outlawed. The disastrous decline in the Welsh language in Mawr is due to almost unbelievably poor and remote government. Every single house in a Bro Iaith should be put into Trust on behalf of the Welsh language. Gradually the situation of a hundred years ago would be restored, and there would be no need to speak English. The sale of alcohol and tobacco should be prohibited in Mawr, and the licences of pubs withdrawn. Alcoholism and cancer due to tobacco are very serious problems. Elderly people often face isolation due to language loss. Many can hardly speak English, and are forced to speak English by wholly inconsiderate people who will not learn a word of Welsh. I am frequently asked why the old community has been allowed to deteriorate so badly. I decided to try to help with cleaning up the Elim grounds and graveyard because they are in such a terrible mess.

Daily Report Saturday 25/4/15

April 27, 2015

There were 3,127 files downloaded from 416 reading sessions during the day, main spiders baidu, google, MSN, yandex and yahoo. Evans / Morris papers 417, Scientometrics 236, Auto1 214, Auto2 73, F3(Sp) 212, Eckardt / Lindstrom papers 186, Principles of ECE 169, UFT88 124, UFT311 117, Engineering Model 95, Evans Equations 79 (numerous Spanish), Llais 62, Proof One 58, Proof Two 17, Proof Four 16, Englynion 55 (second book of poetry); CEFE 52, Autobiography Sonnets 17 (first book of poetry) to date in April 2015. University of Arizona UFT202; Harvard University general; Cambridge University Essay 15, General Relativity and Particle Scattering. Intense interest all sectors, updated usage file attached for April 2015.

Mrs John Jones Pen yr Heol Fach

April 26, 2015

Bu farw Mrs John Jones Pen yr Heol Fach ar ol flynyddoedd o ddioddef. Welais John Jones heddiw a fe ddywedodd yn dawel wrthof: “Mae fy nghwraig annwyl i wedi mynd” – ar ol trigain mlynedd a mwy fel g^wr a gwraig. Gofynnodd a byddai’n gallu siarad a mi pob dydd yng Nghymraeg. Wrth gwrs gnwaf yr union beth ar fy nhro i fynu i’r ffarm bach pob dydd. Gobeithio bydd ei gymdogion a’i deulu yn cadw llygad arno. Mae e’n naw deg pump mlwydd oed ac yn dioddef gyda’i gefen a siom. “Gwyn eu byd y rhai addfwyn, canys hwy a etifeddant y ddaear”. Mrs John Jones Pen yr Heol Fach died after years of suffering. I saw John Jones today and he quietly told me: “My own dear wife has gone” after sixty years and more as husband and wife. He asked me whether I would speak to him in Welsh every day. Of course I will do this on my walk up to the little farm every day. I hope that his neighbours and family will keep an eye on him. He is ninety five years old and suffering badly from his back and shock. “Blessed are the meek, for they shall inherit the earth.”

General Election: Urgent Reforms Needed in Mawr

April 26, 2015

As a member of the Gentry (untitled nobility) and of newly discovered royal descent (“Burke’s Peerage and Gentry” 2012) I will not vote (this is traditional) but can offer a few comments on very urgently needed reform in Mawr, mainly to save the Welsh language from extinction. I am also a U. S. citizen so can act as an impartial international observer. Only one candidate talked to me during the campaign, Elizabeth Evans, Labour. I am a Bevanite Socialist and republican nationalist being born the son of a poor hill farmer and coal miner to a Welsh speaking family. I was raised to the Gentry purely on merit. I discussed many of these points as Armiger with the prospective M. P. for Gower. Discussions lasted an hour and covered many points such as the following upon which almost complete agreement was obtained.

1) Compulsory education for all in the Welsh language for all in Wales from age three to seventeen, reopening of Welsh language schools in Mawr. The aim is that everyone in Wales must be able to speak Welsh. What is wrong with that? Free education for all in Wales, from cradle to grave.
2) Demolition of wind turbines throughout Wales, demolition of the Betws development and prevention of the Mynydd y Gwair development. The Labour Party should change its views on useless wind turbines.
3) Nationalization under Bevanite socialist principles of all land owned by absentee landlords in Wales, notably the Somerset Trust. The latter has allowed Gelliwastad to be ruined by illegal and trespassing horses and bikers and is a purely exploitative regime, a parasitic load on the working classes.
4) Gelliwastad and other areas to be sealed off by gates and fencing, with access only to walkers. It is a protected ecology that has been completely ruined.
5) Reform and suspension of the Community Council, pending inquiry. Prosecution if necessary. It was recently found once more to be a disfunctional Council earlier this year by Audit Office Wales. It was severely reprimanded and this is public knowledge. Its accounts have been out of order for years and I have distanced myself as Armiger from the Council. There are nearly a hundred accounts irregularities
6) All Councillors and Council workers to be personally fluent in Welsh, not just able to say “Bore Da” as at present. I was recently told by an arrogant and hostile Swansea Council worker that this is an English speaking area, which is news to me. This deeply offensive attitude to be eliminated. It is a blatant violation of Human Rights showing that the old prejudice against the Welsh language is as sad and bigoted as ever.
7) All cars to be removed from the roads of Mawr, double yellow lines and speeding restrictions introduced, traffic wardens and increased pavement edges and bollards to physically prevent cars from parking on pavements. Many pavements have been badly damaged by cars in Mawr, the roads are narrow, and people are forced in to the path of a very heavy, speeding car. This is what the police want in Mawr – double yellow lines and a total parking ban using double yellow lines and many other means. Parking areas to be introduced for off the road parking.
8) Sentences for biker and horse vandals to be increased. I favour a term of hard labour, a shift underground would do them no harm so anthracite mines could be used for this purpose. Horse riding to be restricted to private land only, horses to banned from roads throughout Mawr, bridle paths rescinded. This is because of heavy damage and fouling by horses, and road blocking. At present local people have to clean up the roads.
9) Mawr to become a Language Nest or Bro Iaith in which all are educated in Welsh and in English. This establishes an area in which use of the English language is unnecessary and people would not be forced to speak English as at present. All its chapels to be rigorously protected by CADW. People have a right to speak their own language without being expected to slavishly switch to English. You will not be transported for this any more, or bayoneted as in the Irish film “The Wind that Shakes the Barley”.
10) New legislation to allow the police to tow and crush cars trespassing illegally on land that does not belong to them. Blatant trespassing should become a criminal offence. This towing and crushing should be done without compensation. At present we are told that neither the police nor the council can do anything at all about trespassers. If so, why have our taxes tripled in a decade?
11) Complete opposition to lunatic plans to saturate the Swansea area with thirty thousand new houses for commuters to Cardiff or even London. There will be no fuel available, and in general the profligate and wasteful lifestyle of the present era will very soon come to an end as the fuel runs out. These plans will completely destroy small communities. Cars in Mawr are far too large, there are ten times too many of them, and roads are nearly choked. Introduction of commuter trains and buses.
12) Opposition to the saturation of Wales with foreign students and massive new universities, the only university needed in Wales is one that operates entirely in Welsh. If people do not like this they can seek their education outside the borders of Wales. Working class families cannot afford to send their children to these educational establishments reserved for the children of the foreign rich. They do not even know that the Welsh language exists.

Myron Evans,
Armiger in Mawr and Surrounding Areas.

Discussions about Maintaining Elim Craig Cefn Parc

April 26, 2015

To Trustees, Newlands Family Trust,

I will discuss the maintenance of this historic 1839 chapel with the Treasurer on Thursday, in particular the donation of funds to maintain the building, grounds and graveyard. It is more or less a family chapel (Jones, Hopkin, Havard) and I also think that all the chapels in Mawr should be Grade A listed by CADW and rigorously protected. If volunteers could help clean up the grounds and graveyard it would be much appreciated, but I can discuss finding a gardener to do this. Precious heritage such as this should always be kept in pristine condition and never sold. I think that legislation should be introduced to prohibit people living in chapels and churches. Many people think that this is not right. The Italians would not allow anyone to live in the Pazzi Chapel in Florence for example. The French would not allow anyone to live in Chartres or Vezelay. I think that the Llan Giwg Community could work with Elim to make use of it for readings of cynghanedd and so on, and of course for the traditional Welsh Baptist service and singing. All these traditions should be revived. I think that an ecumenical line of thought is needed, otherwise the entire culture will disappear.

Discussion of note 313(5)

April 26, 2015

Many thanks again for going through these difficult and very complicated calculations. The final version of the Jacobi method to be used in UFT313 is Note 313(6). In general the commutator [D sub mu,D sub nu] is not zero, as you know, so covariant derivatives cannot be exchanged, in the sense that D sub mu D sub nu – D sub nu D sub mu acting on a vector or tensor is not zero. In other words they do not commute. Note 313(6) was the method used by Ricci and Bianchi. It took me more than twenty years of research to find this method, which is by no means obvious in any way. Ryder casually mentions that the method is obvious and Carroll gives no details. They both leave it to the student. I guess that no student ever went through it. In Eq. (1) the Jacobi identity acts on a vector. That is the first important point. Both Ryder and Carroll omit the vector. Considering the first term as in Eq. (2) the Leibnitz theorem is used. This introduces the commutator acting on a rank two tensor, D sub rho V sup kappa. The general formula for the covariant derivative acting on any tensor is Eq. (6), which is exceedingly intricate. Bianchi in 1902 omitted torsion and used Eq. (4). We know now that he should have used Eq. (3). Eq. (4) is simply wrong, because if torsion is omitted, mu = nu in Eq. (3) and the commutator and curvature both vanish, and gravitation vanishes. By now the enlightened colleagues worldwide have accepted this point. So Bianchi arrived at Eq. (5) in which the first term of the second Bianchi identity of 1902 can be seen on the right hand side, but a commutator term is subtracted from it. By reducing the general formula (6) this commutator term becomes the Ricci identity (8). This is not even mentioned in the the vast majority of textbooks, including Ryder and Carroll. No student could possibly have ever derived it. So by using the complete Jacobi identity the result (9) is obtained. Using the first Bianchi identity one finally arrives at Eq. (10), establishing the relation between the exact Jacobi identity and inexact torsionless second Bianchi identity. Note that there is summation of repeated lambda indices so the usual second Bianchi identity is a special solution. The actual result is equivalent to A dot B = 0. and obviously A = 0 is only one out of many possible solutions.Now restore torsion and the correct second Bianchi identity with torsion becomes Eq. (20). This is named the Jacobi Cartan Evans identity to make it clear that torsion changes things entirely. We can use my cyclical torsion identity of UFT109, Eq. (21), to simplify this a little. I name this the first Evans Identity because it was missed completely during the entire Einsteinian era. Eq. (22) may be true in special circumstances, so I name that the second Evans identity. Then the JCE identity reduces to Eq. (23). There is no way that any student could ever have derived this result. Finally Note 313(7) gives the proof of the first Evans identity, first given in UFT109. I went through all the calculations again and checked everything. It relies on the exceedingly intricate formula (2) for the covariant derivative of any tensor. I think that the readership threw up when they saw this snowstrom of indices, but I like this identity very much, it is elegant and can be used to derive a cyclical identity of field tensors in electromagnetism and gravitation. It is most satisfactory to find that it is part of the JCE identity. When Grossmann told Einstein about the second Bianchi identity of 1902 it had already become cut in stone, and was already erroneously thought to be exact (circa 1905). In fact it is totally wrong. So if people go on using it they would have left things to the student. Any lecturer can do that by not turning up at lectures.

To: Emyrone@aol.com
Sent: 25/04/2015 16:47:02 GMT Daylight Time
Subj: note 313(5)

Can two covariant derivatives be interchanged? The derivatives could
impact the contained Christoffel symbols/spin connections differently.

Discussion of note 313(4)

April 26, 2015

Eq. (15) of Note 313(2) is constructed from Eq. (14) of that note, which is an exact identity. So Eq. (15) is also an exact identity. Eq. (16) of that note is Eq. (105) of UFT255. It is assumed that Eq. (16) is a solution of Eq. (15). Adding Eqs. (15) and (16) gives Eq. (1) of Note 303(4), which shows that Eq. (16) is true, and so is a solution of Eq. (15). The identities (5) and (6) of Note 313(4) are obtained from the identity (3) by cyclic permutation of the indices lambda, nu and rho. In the same way, these indices can be cyclically permuted in the Cartan identity (2).

Sent: 25/04/2015 16:17:03 GMT Daylight Time
Subj: note 313(4)

Eq.(1) is constructed in a way that the terms in each line come from
known identities, thus making their sum valid.
I do not understand why the new identities (4-6) should be valid in
general. These seem to be constructed from columns of eq.(1). In this
way their validity is sufficient to validate (1), but the conditions
(4-6) are not necessary to fulfill (1), it is not an equivalence relation.
Eq.(3) is the second Bianchi identity and valid independently.

Horst

Discussion of Note 313(3)

April 26, 2015

Agreed with this, the final version of this method is Note 313(6), which develops the Ricci identity.

To: Emyrone@aol.com
Sent: 25/04/2015 16:08:50 GMT Daylight Time
Subj: note 313(3)

In eq. (4) one could write the vector V outside of the commutators, then
the left-side operator could be avoided, but this is only a formal aspect.
The new identities are true “operator equations” because the derivatives
of the vector V they operate on have to be taken, reminds to quantum
mechanics.

Horst

Discussion of note 313(2)

April 26, 2015

Agreed with this, the main purpose of UFT313 is to check UFT255, Eq. (105) and to show that when torsion is considered the Einstein theory becomes unworkable, the entire twentieth century in general relativity becomes meaningless. This series of papers started of course with the famous UFT88. The second Bianchi identity with torsion can give a field equation which may be worth developing, but the ECE field equations based on the Cartan identity (UFT303) are far simpler and more powerful, and by now highly developed. What is more, the entire world of enlightened science seems to agree.

To: Emyrone@aol.com
Sent: 25/04/2015 15:05:37 GMT Daylight Time
Subj: note 313(2)

This note is more clear than the previous one. The second Bianchi
identity (16) is combined with (14) which is derived from the first
Bianchi identity.
Field equations can be derived, but the curvature terms in (20) remain.
It could be that they can be related to the charge and current densities
as defined in earlier work. In (19) you used the second Bianchi identity
without additional terms from (17), this is reasonable, otherwise it
would unnecessarily complicate the new field equations.

Horst


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 31 other followers